As Thanksgiving draws the near, the question of what wine to buy and serve tends to elicit undue stress. There is something about a holiday that revolves around a single meal, and is so complex in its ingredients and flavor profiles, that a normally confident wine shopper, buckles under the pressure. Light meat, dark meat, gravy, cream, cranberry and assorted spices, all on one plate, and before 5 PM. How can one wine fit the bill? Truth is that it can’t….it’s exhausting, and I have read the countless articles and blogs to prove it!
If going at it alone, the best thing to do is choose a wine varietal that you like and is well balanced so as to not fight the meal. White wines that tend to compliment the Thanksgiving feast are Sauvignon Blanc, Dry Riesling, Sancerre and Chablis/Meursault. As for a red wine, it is hard to beat Pinot Noir, but others to try are Beaujolais (not nouveau!) and Côtes du Rhône.
For specific wine suggestions, its best to seek out the advice of a great local wine shop. I called on two local experts to provide some guidance on the topic, and they offered up these wonderful suggestions.
Nicole Miranda, VP of Marketing at Sokolin recommends:
RED: Roessler Pinot Noir La Brisa 2007 $27.95
92 Points – Wine Spectator
“Tightly structured, firm and concentrated, with a trim beam of spice, earthen floor, dried currant and cranberry fruit that holds onto its earthy tannins through the long finish. Drink now through 2013…” - Wine Spectator
WHITE: Varner Foxglove Chardonnay 2008 (California Central Coast) $14.95
91 Points – Robert Parker
“…Loads of tropical fruit, honeysuckle, and orange blossom notes fill the olfactory sense, as does the luscious medium-bodied texture on the palate. The wine is buttressed by crisp underlying acidity, and the result is a fresh, naked expression of Chardonnay that is top-flight. Drink it over the next year or so.” - Robert Parker
ROSE: d’Esclans Rose Whispering Angel 2008 (Provence, France) $17.95
92 Points – Dave Sokolin
“On the lighter side, creamy and elegant, with fresh raspberry and glazed citrus flavors, followed by a lively and well-spiced finish. Drink now…” - Wine Spectator
Michael Chait, owner of Marquis Wine in Locust Valley (516-671-1578) recommends:
WHITE: Groth Sauvignon Blanc 2008 $21.99
This crowd pleaser is perfect for your Thanksgiving feast! Aromas of fresh melon and citrus fruits are surrounding this slightly creamy, yet crisp white. Great wine to serve to guests as they enter your home or through out the entire meal.
RED: Charles Krug Pinot Noir 2006 $29.99
Aromas of strawberry, ripe plum and black cherry are followed by toasty oak and velvety tannins that leave you with a long lasting finish. Great wine to pair with your bird or to sip on its own. A wine that is sure not to leave your guests or your Turkey disappointed!
AND a last minute addition from Michael Skurnik’s newsletter; always a great resource:
RED: Brick House, Gamay Noir 2008, (Willamette, Oregon) $25.99
Today, Gamay is largely relegated to Beaujolais, a region just south of the Cote d’Or that Burgundians have on occasion claimed as their own. The soils around these locales in upper Beaujolais are rich in mica and silica and are far more acidic than those of Burgundy. In these respects, New World growers in Oregon have much in common with those in Beaujolais. This wine is ripe and delicious, with bright fruit and great acidity. A true wine-lovers wine, but with an adoringly playful nature. Perfect for drinking while sitting around the table with your family, discussing what you are thankful for!
WHITE: Selbach-Oster, Zeltinger Himmelreich Riesling Spätlese ‘Anrecht’ 2008 $25.99
This wine is from a bloc-picking of the best parcel in the Zeltinger Himmelreich ‘Anrecht’, a filet-piece of the vineyard, steep and south-facing, which amounted to two fuders. Nothing will pair more gracefully with the myriad of foods at your Thanksgiving table–from sweet yams to braised greens and rich roasted Turkey. The gentle richness on the palate will marry up to all of the comfort foods to be enjoyed, and the mineralic/acid complexities will help the mouth stay fresh and light throughout the entire day, no palate fatigue here. Plus it contains lower than typical alcohol, making it a wine that won’t bog you down during the epic feast.